Quick Answer: “Look Before You LIRP” by David McKnight is an essential guide for anyone considering a Life Insurance Retirement Plan. The book explains how to evaluate Indexed Universal Life policies for retirement income, covering key factors like fees, growth potential, tax-free distributions, and long-term care benefits. It’s a must-read before choosing your LIRP provider.
If you’ve read David McKnight’s “The Power of Zero,” you already understand why getting to the 0% tax bracket matters for retirement. But here’s the question that book left unanswered: which life insurance product should you actually use to get there?
That’s exactly what “Look Before You LIRP” addresses. Think of it as the practical follow-up guide. McKnight makes his case for Indexed Universal Life as the foundation of a solid retirement strategy, then walks you through exactly what to look for before you commit. We’ve recommended this book to clients for years because it asks the right questions before you sign on the dotted line.
What Is a LIRP and Why Does It Matter?
A LIRP (Life Insurance Retirement Plan) uses permanent life insurance to build tax-free retirement income. In The Power of Zero, McKnight argues convincingly that tax rates will rise in the future. His math is simple: if your retirement income is tax-free, it doesn’t matter if rates double or triple. Two times zero is still zero.
Smart. Flexible. Secure. Protect Your Future with IUL.
Discover the Power of Indexed Universal Life Insurance.
But not all LIRPs are created equal. That’s the whole point of this book. McKnight compares choosing your LIRP to getting married. You wouldn’t say “I do” without knowing what you’re getting into. The same logic applies here.
Chapter 1: Finding the Right LIRP
McKnight opens by laying out six reasons why a LIRP stands apart from other retirement vehicles:
No withdrawal penalties. Unlike a 401(k) or IRA, you can access your money before age 59½ without penalties.
No 1099 forms. The growth in your LIRP isn’t reported as taxable income each year. That’s significant savings over a 20 or 30-year retirement.
Distributions aren’t counted as income. When you take money out the right way, it doesn’t affect your Social Security benefits or push you into a higher tax bracket.
No contribution limits. Traditional retirement plans cap what you can put in each year. LIRPs don’t have those restrictions. Your contributions tie to your death benefit instead.
No income limits. High earners who can’t contribute to a Roth IRA have no such restrictions with a LIRP.
Legislative protection. When Congress has changed LIRP rules in the past, they’ve grandfathered existing policies. Your plan stays protected.
McKnight then outlines four characteristics you should look for in any Indexed Universal Life policy: safe and productive growth, low fees, tax-free and cost-free distributions, and a long-term care rider. Each gets its own chapter.
Chapter 2: Safe and Productive Growth
Here’s where McKnight explains the cap and floor concept that makes IUL unique. You get market-linked growth with downside protection. Sounds too good to be true, right? Let us explain how it actually works.
Your policy has a “cap” (the maximum you can earn) and a “floor” (the minimum, usually 0%). If the index gains 16% but your cap is 13%, you’re credited 13%. If the market drops 20%, you lose nothing because the floor protects you.
McKnight includes a comparison that really drives this home. Here’s what happened to $1,000,000 invested from 2001 to 2015:
| Year | S&P 500 Return | S&P 500 Value | IUL Value (14% Cap, 0% Floor) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2001 | -13.04% | $869,600 | $1,000,000 |
| 2002 | -23.37% | $666,374 | $1,000,000 |
| 2003 | +26.38% | $842,163 | $1,140,000 |
| 2004 | +8.99% | $917,873 | $1,242,486 |
| 2005 | +3.00% | $945,409 | $1,279,760 |
| 2006 | +13.62% | $1,074,173 | $1,454,063 |
| 2007 | +3.53% | $1,112,091 | $1,505,391 |
| 2008 | -38.49% | $684,047 | $1,505,391 |
| 2009 | +23.45% | $844,456 | $1,716,145 |
| 2010 | +12.78% | $952,377 | $1,935,468 |
| 2011 | 0.00% | $952,377 | $1,935,468 |
| 2012 | +13.41% | $1,080,090 | $2,195,014 |
| 2013 | +29.60% | $1,399,796 | $2,502,315 |
| 2014 | +11.39% | $1,559,232 | $2,787,328 |
| 2015 | -0.73% | $1,547,849 | $2,787,328 |
| Total Return | 2.95% | 7.07% |
The difference is striking. The IUL ended up nearly $1.2 million ahead, primarily because it avoided the devastating losses in 2001, 2002, and 2008. That’s what the floor does for you.
Chapter 3: Low Fees
Every investment has fees. That’s reality. But McKnight makes an important point: you need to compare fees correctly.
A Roth IRA charges fees based on your account balance. As your money grows, so do your fees. An IUL charges fees based on your death benefit, which stays relatively fixed. Over a 30-year period, this difference compounds significantly in your favor.
McKnight runs the numbers across several pages, but the takeaway is clear. When you’re earning solid returns with reasonable fees, your LIRP delivers real retirement income. When fees eat into those returns, the whole strategy suffers.
Chapter 4: Tax-Free and Cost-Free Distributions
This chapter addresses something many people miss. Tax-free distributions are great, but cost-free distributions matter just as much.
Here’s how it works. When you want retirement income from your IUL, you don’t withdraw the money directly. Instead, you take a policy loan. The IRS doesn’t consider loans as income, so there’s no tax. Your money moves to a collateral account where it keeps earning interest while the insurance company sends you a check.
The key question: what interest rate does the company charge on that loan versus what they pay on your collateral? If those rates match, you break even. If they don’t, you could end up paying more interest than you’re earning.
McKnight’s advice is straightforward. Don’t do business with a company that reserves the right to charge more interest on loans than they pay on your collateral. This is where working with an experienced advisor really matters. We’ve seen policies with unfavorable loan provisions, and they can quietly erode your retirement income.
Chapter 5: The Long-Term Care Rider
We consider this one of the most important chapters in the book. Here’s a reality check: there’s roughly a 70% chance that at least one spouse will need long-term care. That expense can wipe out a lifetime of savings.
Traditional options include self-insuring (risky), relying on family (unpredictable), or buying standalone long-term care insurance (expensive and you might never use it).
McKnight presents an alternative: a long-term care rider on your IUL, ideally one that doesn’t require additional premium. Here’s the basic structure. If you need long-term care, the company accelerates your death benefit to pay for it. A typical arrangement pays 2% of your death benefit monthly for up to four years.
There’s a discount based on your age when you access the benefit. At 75, you might receive 75% of the full amount. So instead of $8,000 monthly from a $400,000 death benefit, you’d get $6,000.
The tradeoff makes sense for many people. If you never need long-term care, your beneficiaries get the full death benefit plus your cash value. You didn’t pay extra premiums for coverage you never used. If you do need care, you have a funded benefit ready.
What McKnight Gets Right
In the final chapters, McKnight addresses the myths and misinformation you’ll find when researching LIRPs online. He’s honest that every financial professional tends to favor their own products. That’s human nature.
His recommendation: do your homework before committing. Compare multiple IUL providers. Understand the cap rates, fee structures, and loan provisions. Ask about long-term care riders. And work with an advisor who specializes in this area.
We’ve been helping clients evaluate IUL policies for over 30 years. McKnight’s book gives you the framework to ask the right questions. That’s exactly what you need before making a decision that affects your entire retirement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is “Look Before You LIRP” about?
David McKnight’s book explains how to evaluate Life Insurance Retirement Plans, specifically Indexed Universal Life policies. It covers the key factors that separate good policies from problematic ones, including growth potential, fees, distribution costs, and long-term care benefits.
Do I need to read “The Power of Zero” first?
It helps but isn’t required. “The Power of Zero” makes the case for tax-free retirement income. “Look Before You LIRP” assumes you’re already convinced and focuses on implementation. You can start with either book, though reading both gives you the complete picture.
Is Indexed Universal Life the only option for a LIRP?
No, but McKnight argues it’s the best option for most people. Whole life and variable universal life can also function as LIRPs, but IUL offers a unique combination of growth potential and downside protection that the other products don’t match.
How do I know if a LIRP is right for me?
A LIRP works best for people who have maxed out traditional retirement accounts, want tax-free income in retirement, and have a time horizon of at least 10 to 15 years. It’s not ideal for short-term savings or those who might need to access all their cash quickly.
Where can I get “Look Before You LIRP”?
The book is available on Amazon and through most major booksellers. It’s a quick read that could save you from costly mistakes when choosing your retirement strategy.
Key Takeaways
- LIRPs offer unique tax advantages that traditional retirement accounts can’t match, including no contribution limits, no income restrictions, and tax-free distributions that don’t affect Social Security.
- Not all IUL policies are equal. The cap rate, floor rate, fee structure, and loan provisions vary significantly between carriers. Choosing the wrong one can undermine your entire retirement strategy.
- The floor protects you from market crashes. McKnight’s 15-year comparison shows how avoiding losses in down years can result in dramatically higher long-term returns than direct market investment.
- Long-term care is a real risk. With a 70% chance one spouse will need care, having an LTC rider on your IUL provides protection without paying premiums for standalone coverage you might never use.
- Work with a specialist. The details matter with IUL policies. An advisor who understands LIRP structures can help you avoid policies with unfavorable loan provisions or excessive fees.
Want to discuss whether a LIRP makes sense for your retirement? We’re happy to walk through your situation and answer questions. No pressure, just an honest conversation about your options.
Schedule a Free Consultation | Call 800-712-8519
